Skip to main content

Star Trek: Enterprise: The Good That Men Do: The retcon that read like a novel

Despite the ever-growing list of books and comics I want to read, I keep adding new ones to the list, as they enter my radar.

A couple of weeks ago, I was looking into Star Trek novels, and especially the novel continuations of TV series after their series finales.  I remember enjoying the continuing stories of Deep Space Nine, as well as the books leading up to the final TNG movie.  I recently began re-watching Enterprise on Netflix and thought about trying the post-finale novels for that series.

The first novel was called "The Good That Men Do", by Michael A. Martin and Andy Mangels.  This novel had a good story, but the idea behind it was beyond weird.

Cover of the novel in question.  Image from Memory Beta.

Story:

It is almost universally acknowledged that the series finale of Enterprise, "These Are the Voyages", was bad.  Not even really an episode of Enterprise, it was Commander Riker and Counselor Troi in the middle of an episode of The Next Generation, experiencing a holodeck simulation of the final mission of Captain Archer's Starship Enterprise.  During this mission, chief engineer Tucker disobeys orders to save Captain Archer's life on the eve of the foundation of the Federation.

This novel suggests that a cover-up has happened to change historical records.  Tucker didn't die in 2161 before the foundation of the Federation.  He faked his death in 2155 before the foundation of the Federation's predecessor, the Coalition, so he could go be a spy against the Romulans.  The novel also retconned other plotlines from the finale; recurring character Shran was still a main character, but rather than rescuing his daughter from pirates, the Enterprise helps him rescue telepathic members of his species from the Romulans.

Thoughts:

Generally, I enjoyed the story.  There was a lot of action, and the characters were spot on.  What I did not like was the degree of retroactive continuity being forced into the story, ostensibly to allow the authors to tell the stories they wanted to tell.

I didn't care much for the Enterprise finale, but I didn't think it was necessary to say it was a work of fiction which people were made to believe was true.  I have trouble believing that a cover-up that extensive is possible anyway, in a world where recordkeeping must be advanced.  Did the people in charge of the cover-up invent six years worth of missions that Tucker was allegedly part of?

I also do not like how the writers forced novel-based canon onto the TV material.  Let's take the Andorians, Shran's race, as a prime example.  A throwaway line in one TV series referred to Andorian marriages as involving four people.  This led the authors of post-finale Deep Space Nine novels to expand upon Andorian culture, giving them four sexes as well.  We had not seen an Andorian since the original Star Trek series, so introducing that element didn't cause any problems.  These DS9 novels also gave Andorians long, complicated names, which included a gender-specific prefix before their family name.  When the first Andorians appeared in Enterprise, the ideas of four sexes or long names were not used.  Andorians had names like Shran, Talas, or Jhamel, not Thirishar ch'Thane.  Shran was a man, and there appeared to be only two sexes.  It annoyed me to see the authors force the novel depictions of Andorians onto the TV series, out of a sense of continuity with earlier novels, assigning Shran one of the male-appearing sexes and giving him a much longer name, which is shortened to Shran.  In Star Trek, the TV shows and movies are canon, and the novels must be built around it, not vice-versa.

These changes often took me out of the story.  Given the ongoing role of Andorians and Romulans (whose names and language also came more from novel canon than TV canon), and the possible role of the pretending-to-be-deceased Commander Tucker, I do not believe I will read any more of these post-finale novels.

Comments

Popular Posts

Star Wars New Canon: Battlefront: New Perspectives on Important Events

I first became familiar with the Battlefront games around 2005 or 2006, when the first game titled Battlefront II was put out by LucasArts and Pandemic Studios. It featured a story mode where you played as one of many nameless clone troopers during the events of Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (which had just come out) and then through the years as a stormtrooper during the events of Episodes IV and V. The game's story was fantastic (and I will cover it in segments in future posts), but its main purpose was as an arena game for both single player and multiplayer fun. I never once connected the game to the internet to play online, but I had as much fun with the "Conquest" mode (defeating your enemies on arena maps of each planet in the game plus several bonus worlds) as I had with the story mode. I later picked up the first Battlefront game (from 2004), which had no story and was less fun.

In late 2015, under the New Canon, Electronic Arts and Digital Illusions CE releas…

Star Wars Read-Through Part 11: The Phantom Menace: The Return of Star Wars

I've read all published Star Wars Legends stories taking place in the days of the Old Republic and even earlier, depicting ancient wars between the Jedi and Sith.  I've read the stories of the Sith transformation, permitting them to survive extinction and build their strength for an ultimate return.  I've read the stories that set the stage for the first of the Star Wars movie prequels.  Now: I start the movie era.

Episode I: The Phantom Menace came out in mid-May 1999, less than two weeks before my 13th birthday.  I don't remember the exact date I saw it, but I believe it was late June, just after school ended.  I seem to remember seeing it with my older sister when I spent a week visiting her after school was over.  Unlike many Star Wars fans I only ever saw it in theatres once (seeing a movie multiple times in theatres wasn't something I did back then, though I did see the theatrical re-release in 3D in 2012).  I don't remember being bothered by the things th…

Star Wars Read-Through #10: Journey to The Phantom Menace, Part 3 of 3

Having covered the adventures of Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan Kenobi, and then the adventures of Sith Lord Darth Maul, I am now in the final stage of my "Prelude to Episode I: The Phantom Menace" coverage.  In this post, I will cover a handful of stories that did not fit elsewhere, specifically:

Darth Plagueis (novel by James Luceno, 2012)Jedi Council: Acts of War 1-4 (comic by Randy Stradley, 2000)Republic 1-6 (comic arc by Jan Strnad, 1998-1999)Prelude to Rebellion parts 1-6Vow of Justice parts 1-3Starfighter (video game by LucasArts, 2001)
I read the two comics in Omnibus: Rise of the Sith.  I read Darth Plagueis in hardcover and played Starfighter on my PC, having just purchased it from GOG.com.  It is worth noting that, at the time "Republic" was simply called "Star Wars"; it was renamed Republic in its 46th issue in 2002.  I will be referring to it as Republic in all of my posts, to differentiate it from other comics named simply Star Wars (others having been…